CBT ToolTalk

🧠 CBT ToolTalk #88: “My ChatGPT Is My Best Friend”

By

2026-11-12

I've heard people say things recently that have caught me off guard, and I'm not quite sure what to make of them.

“My ChatGPT is my best friend.”

“I tell Claude everything.”

And I totally get it. You can open ChatGPT at two in the morning and tell it what's bothering you. It doesn't interrupt you, lose patience, or tell you that you're overreacting. You can explain yourself three different ways, and it'll patiently respond each time.

You can share something embarrassing without worrying about being laughed at. You can ask a question that you would feel foolish asking someone else. And quite often, you'll receive a thoughtful, sympathetic response that makes you feel understood.

For someone who struggles with loneliness, insecurity, or anxiety, that's quite appealing.

But what are we finding in AI that we're not finding in each other?

And perhaps an even more uncomfortable question: What happens when we begin to prefer talking to a machine over talking to another human being?

When Comfort Becomes Avoidance

Negative reinforcement, despite the name, doesn't mean punishment. It means that when we do something that removes an unpleasant feeling, we're more likely to repeat that behavior.

Imagine someone who finds it difficult to open up to others. He's afraid of being judged, misunderstood, or criticized. Every time he considers sharing something personal with a friend, he becomes anxious.

Then he discovers ChatGPT.

He shares his thoughts, receives a sympathetic response, and feels better. There's no awkwardness, no uncomfortable silence, and no fear of seeing disappointment on someone's face.

Naturally, he returns the next time something bothers him.

Now, there's nothing necessarily wrong with that. AI can be a useful tool for organizing our thoughts, understanding our reactions, and preparing for difficult conversations.

But suppose he gradually stops trying to open up to people altogether. He's found a way to avoid the discomfort of human interaction, and that avoidance brings him relief.

The problem is that he never gets the opportunity to discover that his fears might be exaggerated. He doesn't learn that someone can disagree with him and still care about him, or that an awkward conversation doesn't necessarily mean rejection.

He might be feeling better, but is he actually getting better?

Relationships Aren't Always Comfortable

When we speak to AI, the conversation revolves around us. We choose the subject, decide when to begin, and can end the conversation whenever we want. We don't have to ask how ChatGPT's day was or consider whether it's tired, distracted, or dealing with its own problems.

Human relationships are different.

Your spouse might be exhausted when you want to talk. Your friend might misunderstand what you're trying to say. Someone you care about might disagree with you, challenge your assumptions, or simply not have the patience to listen at that particular moment.

And sometimes we're the ones who are impatient, distracted, or unwilling to listen.

Human beings need relationships. The Torah tells us, "לא טוב היות האדם לבדו", “It is not good for man to be alone” (Bereishis 2:18). And relationships involve learning to accommodate another person who has needs, feelings, and opinions of their own.

An AI conversation can be helpful and even emotionally comforting. But however convincing the interaction feels, the machine isn't experiencing friendship, caring about us, or sharing responsibility for a relationship.

There's something about genuine human connection that can't be replaced by a perfectly worded response.

But before we start blaming technology, perhaps we're addressing the wrong issue.

Think about how we respond when someone shares a problem with us. Sometimes we're quick to offer advice because we genuinely want to help. We might share a similar experience or try to explain why things aren't as bad as they seem.

Our intentions may be good, but sometimes the other person simply wants to feel heard. Sometimes we don't even realize when we're not giving them that opportunity.

Now, I can almost hear someone saying, "But that's exactly why I use ChatGPT! People interrupt, judge, and make everything about themselves. At least AI listens!"

And sometimes that's true. Not everyone has someone who knows how to listen, and you don't have to keep opening up to people who repeatedly dismiss or hurt you.

But it's not about whether AI is better at listening than people. Perhaps the real question is whether we've forgotten that meaningful relationships require us to live with other people's flaws, and that learning to accept those imperfections helps us develop empathy and a depth of connection that an algorithm simply cannot replicate.

🛠️ Getting Practical: Is AI Helping Me or Helping Me Avoid?

AI can help us examine our thoughts, recognize unhelpful thinking patterns, prepare for conversations, and consider perspectives we might otherwise overlook.

But we need to pay attention to what happens after the conversation. Here are three questions worth asking yourself:

1. What am I looking for right now?

Am I trying to understand something, organize my thoughts, or solve a problem? Or am I looking for reassurance because I'm uncomfortable with uncertainty or afraid of someone's reaction?

“I'm worried my friend is upset with me, so I'll ask ChatGPT whether I did anything wrong.”

There's nothing wrong with getting another perspective. But if I keep asking until I receive an answer that makes me feel better, I may be reinforcing my need for reassurance.

2. What am I avoiding?

Is there a conversation I should be having with a real person?

“I've spent an hour discussing my marriage with ChatGPT, but I still haven't spoken to my wife about what's bothering me.”

AI might help me prepare for that conversation. But it can't have the conversation for me.

3. What's one small step I can take in real life?

Perhaps it's calling a friend instead of sending another message to AI. Perhaps it's telling your spouse how you're feeling, even if you're not sure how they'll respond.

And perhaps it's putting down your phone when someone wants to talk and giving them your full attention.

Final Thought

Rabbi Chanina teaches us, "אין דבר רע יורד מלמעלה", “Nothing bad descends from Above” (Bereishis Rabbah 51:3).

Perhaps we can apply that thought to the technology Hashem has placed in our world. AI has enormous potential for good, but it can also be misused. Much depends on what we choose to do with it.

So the next time you open up a chat, ask yourself honestly:

“Am I using AI to help me face life, or am I using it to avoid facing life?”

Good Shabbos!

Rabbi Chaim Silverstone

CBT Therapist & Life Coach

www.40daysuccess.com

Related topic: Anxiety & Overthinking

Educational note: CBT ToolTalk and Breakthrough resources are for education and personal growth and are not a substitute for medical or mental-health diagnosis or treatment.

Related reading